As I’ve started learning about personality psychology, I’ve noticed big parts of the field revolving around the Big Five personality traits, also known as the Five Factor Model. This is a formulation of our common sense idea of personality that makes individual personality traits, and the validity of the model as a whole, experimentally testable. The five traits are Openness to new experience, Conscientiousness, Extraversion, Agreeableness and Neuroticism (OCEAN for short). Each trait is a continuum along which each individual is supposed to occupy a set point that defines their personality as other people experience it. The traits were first identified through exhaustive studies of the frequency of words that people use to describe a personality, and were later confirmed to be pretty stable, predictive, and reflective of how untrained people actually think about personality.
When I first heard about this, I wasn’t so sure it fit with my common sense. Are we all really that simple? Maybe not, or else there wouldn’t be any other subfields of psychology, cognitive science or sociology. But as I’ve jiggled the FFM around in my head and tried to fit it to my relationships, I do find some application, in particular at work.
Catching up with an old friend on the phone last night, he asked me to describe working at my nameless fortune 100 tech giant employer. ”Strange” was the first word that came to mind. The impersonal environment of long, kind of dark hallways and acres of grey cubicles, along with some unusual management practices, can skew day to day interaction way off of life outside. Our review process pits us directly against each other for raises and promotions, with anonymous feedback from coworkers having a big impact the result. The result is a lot of hardworking people, who are less willing than they might be to do anything pro bono or actively solicit help from coworkers on new projects. This much was obvious about the working environment in the first six months I worked here, but as I read about the Big Five I also wondered what kind of personalities we might be selecting for, and how that would affect the feeling of coming into work.
The one trait I really stand out on is openness to new experience. I live for variety, and this is a big part of how I experience working in tech. Any day I can come in and learn a new tool or how some complex device works is a good day. This is such a strong motivator that I have a hard time imagining any other reason to be here, and this blind spot got me into some trouble early. Not everyone who works here is open to new experience; maybe even the opposite. It turns out conscientiousness is the trait most selected for, in the form of attention to detail. This is not one of my strong points. But as for openness, lots of my coworkers have been around here for years (decades), have families and other concerns, and just aren’t that interested in new ways of doing things. When this bright eyed recent college grad came in and started poking at why we don’t do this or that alternative method, I think I established myself as part of an outgroup. Thankfully things have eased up since then with a change of management, some personal development and new requirements for the team. I’ve become more conscientious over time. We’ve also been forced by external circumstances to change, and although not everyone in the group has to like it, it’s been an opportunity for me to explore areas where the right answers haven’t been established in advance. I’m still surprised that I haven’t found this mythical cache of curious engineering types that I expected, but maybe it’s out there. If not, I’m slowly getting better at working with the rest.
Otherwise, the skew in personalities is something like what you would expect for nerds versus the rest of us. You can see the difference in extraversion and agreeableness walking between the engineering and business admin areas. I don’t know if the engineers are more neurotic in general, but there are one or two examples I’m always amazed manage to make it out of the house in the morning.
We’ll see how this changes through my career. Without conducting a survey or experiment myself, I’m just comparing against my own expectations. I’ll probably shift in the direction of my coworkers’ personalities as I get older, get a family of my own, go through all those same cataclysmic lifestyle changes. In the mean time, I’ll just have to keep my mind open to how other people work and think.